Health

Hand & Wrist

Wrist Sprain or Broken Scaphoid? Why Snuffbox Pain Needs an X-ray

Nadeen Al Awamry PT
November 1, 2026
6 mins

You slipped on the ice in the parking lot, or caught an edge snowboarding, and put your hand out to break the fall. Your wrist hurt, but you could still move it. There was a bit of swelling on the thumb side, nothing dramatic. You wrapped it, called it a sprain and carried on.

Two weeks later it still aches when you grip a coffee mug, turn a doorknob or push yourself up from a chair. That lingering thumb-side pain after a fall on an outstretched hand is exactly the pattern that can hide a broken scaphoid.

What is a scaphoid fracture?

The scaphoid is a small, curved bone in your wrist, on the thumb side, linking the two rows of wrist bones. It's the most commonly broken wrist bone. A review in the Hong Kong Medical Journal estimates scaphoid fractures make up 70% to 80% of wrist bone (carpal) fractures, and they are most often seen in young men.

The usual cause is falling onto an outstretched hand with the wrist bent back. Sports like snowboarding, skating, cycling, basketball and rugby, plus winter slips, are common settings.

Here's why it matters: scaphoid fractures are easy to miss and slow to heal. The same review reports that plain X-rays pick up the fracture in about 70% to 90% of cases on the day of injury, so some are not visible at first. The scaphoid also has a fragile blood supply. If a fracture isn't found and protected, it may not heal (non-union), part of the bone can lose its blood supply (avascular necrosis), and arthritis can develop over time. The review reports non-union rates of up to 12% in missed fractures.

Warning signs to know

Get your wrist checked if you fell on an outstretched hand and have:

  • Pain on the thumb side of the wrist
  • Tenderness in the "anatomical snuffbox", the small hollow at the base of the thumb you can see when you stick your thumb out
  • Tenderness over the bump on the palm side of the wrist at the base of the thumb
  • Pain when you pinch with your thumb and index finger, or grip
  • Pain when turning your palm down
  • Swelling or bruising on the thumb side of the wrist
  • Wrist pain that is still there two weeks after the injury

You don't need all of these. The review notes that some classic signs are missing in about a quarter of people who turn out to have a fracture.

When to go to the emergency department

Go to the emergency department (or call 911 if you can't get there safely) if after a wrist injury you have:

  • A wrist that looks bent, twisted or out of shape
  • Bone poking through the skin, or a deep cut that won't stop bleeding
  • Numbness, tingling or pins and needles in the hand or fingers
  • A hand or fingers that change colour

Don't drive yourself. Ask someone to take you.

See a doctor the same day or next day, at urgent care, a walk-in clinic or your family doctor, if you fell on your hand and have thumb-side wrist pain, snuffbox tenderness, swelling or trouble gripping. Ask about a scaphoid fracture specifically.

Because early X-rays can be normal, your doctor may put your wrist in a splint or cast even if the first X-ray looks clear, then arrange follow-up imaging. The UK's NICE fracture guideline suggests considering MRI as the first imaging test for a suspected scaphoid fracture after a thorough exam. CT is another option. Whether you need a cast or surgery depends on where the break is and whether the pieces have moved, and that decision belongs to your doctor or hand surgeon.

Why your physiotherapist asks about this

Lots of people come to physiotherapy with a "sprained wrist" that has been bothering them for weeks. Most are soft tissue injuries. But at Vaughan Physiotherapy Clinic, we don't assume. If you hurt your wrist in a fall, your physiotherapist will ask:

  • Exactly how you fell, and whether your hand was out to catch you
  • Where the pain is, and whether it's on the thumb side
  • Whether you've had an X-ray, and what it showed
  • How the pain has changed since the injury

We'll check for tenderness in the snuffbox and over the scaphoid, and look at grip, pinch and wrist movement. No single test can confirm or rule out a scaphoid fracture. Examination findings raise or lower suspicion, but imaging gives the answer.

If anything points to a possible scaphoid fracture and it hasn't been properly investigated, we stop and refer. We'll protect the wrist, contact your family doctor or send you to urgent care with a note explaining our findings, and hold off on stretching, strengthening or hands-on treatment of the wrist until a fracture is ruled out.

What physiotherapy can and can't do

Physiotherapy can't diagnose a scaphoid fracture or decide on casting or surgery. Those come from your doctor or hand surgeon after imaging. For questions about pain medication, talk to your doctor or pharmacist.

Once your fracture has been treated and you are cleared to start moving, physiotherapy can help with:

  • Regaining wrist and thumb movement after a cast or surgery
  • Rebuilding grip and forearm strength
  • Managing swelling and stiffness
  • A graded return to work, the gym and sport, including weight-bearing through the hands
  • Watching for signs that healing isn't going as expected and flagging them to your surgeon

If it turns out to be a sprain after all, we can treat that too, with peace of mind that nothing has been missed.

Key takeaways

  • Thumb-side wrist pain after a fall on an outstretched hand can be a broken scaphoid, not just a sprain.
  • Snuffbox tenderness is a key warning sign.
  • Early X-rays can miss the fracture, so a splint and follow-up imaging are common.
  • A missed scaphoid fracture can fail to heal and lead to long-term wrist problems.
  • Physiotherapists screen for this, refer before treating, and help with rehab once the bone is managed.

Related reading: Wrist problems that can follow a fall include carpal instability and SLAC wrist.

Wrist still sore after a fall?

If your "sprained" wrist isn't settling, book an assessment. We'll check it carefully, work with your doctor if imaging is needed, and guide your recovery. You can also read our article on snowboarder's wrist.

Call: 905-669-1221

Visit: 398 Steeles Ave W #201, Thornhill, ON

Book online: vaughanphysiotherapy.com

Sources

Cheung, J. P. Y., Tang, C. Y. K., & Fung, B. K. K. (2014). Current management of acute scaphoid fractures: A review. Hong Kong Medical Journal, 20(1), 52-58. https://doi.org/10.12809/hkmj134146

Guy's and St Thomas' NHS Foundation Trust. (2025). Wrist bone (scaphoid) injury. https://guysandstthomas.nhs.uk/health-information/wrist-bone-scaphoid-injury

National Health Service. (2026). Broken arm or wrist. NHS. https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/broken-arm-or-wrist/

National Institute for Health and Care Excellence. (2016). Fractures (non-complex): Assessment and management (NICE guideline NG38). https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ng38

This article is for general information and isn't medical advice. If you have any of the warning signs above, call 911 or contact your doctor right away.

Start Your Journey to 

‍Better Health Today

Recover faster, move better, and feel stronger with expert physiotherapy. Our team is here to guide you every step of the way.

Share this article
Copy Link

Team